Survey shows Diyarbakir residents desire more decentralisation

The survey shows that 50% of respondents said they want ''democratic autonomy.''

By Alakbar Raufoglu for SES Türkiye -- 23/03/12

* denotes required field.

  • Button

As attempts to solve Turkey's Kurdish problem have stalled, a survey published this week by the Diyarbakir-based Centre of Social and Political Research (SAMER) reveals the demand by Diyarbakir's Kurds for some form of decentralised government.

More than 87% of Diyarbakir residents said a referendum is the most effective way to determine their future form of governance. When asked how respondents would vote in a referendum, 49.2% called for ''democratic autonomy'', 19.2% for ''independence'', 5.4% for ''federation'', while 7.1% said ''decentralised administration''. In addition, 3.4% didn't answer and 13% responded that they didn't know.

Answering the question of whether Kurdish should be an official language in Turkey, 83% of the respondents said ''yes'', 9% ''no'', and 8% declined to answer.

Raci Bilici, head of the Human Rights Association's Diyarbakir branch, says that the survey results are ''a big challenge'' for the government.

''The AKP should take it seriously,'' he told SES Türkiye, arguing that many in Diyarbakir are ''deeply disappointed that [Prime Minister Recep Tayyip] Erdogan has not followed through on the promises he stated in the region last year.''

''The AKP promised to take care of both human rights and economic issues in the region, but since then, very little has happened on the positive side while plenty has occurred on the negative side,'' he noted.

In particular, arrests under the ongoing Kurdistan Communities Union (KCK) case, including pro-Kurdish Peace and Democracy Party (BDP) members in local administrations, have had a negative effect on Kurds' perception of the government.

According to the survey, 67.6% of respondents said the KCK trials have had a negative or very negative effect on the Kurdish problem, while 6.4% said there was no effect, 8.8% said a positive or very positive effect, and 17.2% refused to answer.

"The AKP can't go any further [regarding the Kurdish issue] by continuing to arrest people. This makes people more furious and hopeless. The more arrests that happen, the less belief there is left for the AKP in Diyarbakir,'' he said, adding that the government should prove every single case.

However, Ali Ihsan Merdanoglu, a former Kurdish AKP MP from the city, doesn't think such surveys portray the real picture of the region, because people in Diyarbakir are afraid to oppose the PKK's position when asked questions in public.

''The trauma of the PKK's attacks and terrorism campaign is still seared into the memories of those who live here,'' he told SES Türkiye.

The AKP's Mehmet Metiner, a Kurdish deputy, also insists the government's reforms have been significant.

''One can't say these are just small steps. The recognition of the Kurdish problem by our government, the freedom to use Kurdish language, most Kurdish people are satisfied with this," he said.

The AKP will take new steps to advance Kurdish rights, says Professor Ilhan Kaya, chairman of the Diyarbakir-based Dicle University's Social Research Centre, noting that calls for independence are still growing.

''We've also done similar surveys before and it's no secret that the people in Diyarbakir want to see their future under autonomy, so this wasn’t surprising,'' he said.

Most people have traditionally been angry at the government over the social and economic problems Diyarbakir faces, he underlines. In the survey, 33% of respondents said they made between zero and 350 Turkish lira per month (147 euros), while only 3% made over 2,000 Turkish lira (837 euros).

For Ekrem Eddy Guzeldere, an analyst at the Istanbul office of the European Stability Initiative, further explanations regarding the different dimensions of autonomy are required.

''What is clear [in the latest survey] is that not even 20% [of respondents] want independence, but degrees of decentralisation and strengthening of local administrations. This is neither surprising nor spectacular,'' he told SES Türkiye.

In strengthened local administrations, he explains, there should be the possibility to have more than one official language.

''The local administrations should have the right to decide concerning the use of Kurdish, Zazaki [Kurdish], Arabic or other languages in the running of the municipalities and the services provided,'' he added.

SAMER's survey was conducted between March 6-7 in central Diyarbakir, among 300 random participants with a confidence interval of 90% and +/- 5% margin of error.


Do you like this article?



Subscribe to our newsletter and receive our latest published articles in your inbox.

We welcome your comments on SES Türkiye's articles

It is our hope that you will use this forum to interact with other readers across Southeast Europe. In order to keep this experience interesting, we ask you to follow the rules outlined in the comments policy. By submitting comments, you are consenting to these rules. While SES Türkiye encourages discussion on all subjects, including sensitive ones, the comments posted are solely the views of those submitting them. SES Türkiye does not necessarily endorse or agree with the ideas, views, or opinions voiced in these comments. SES Türkiye welcomes constructive discussion but discourages the use of copy-pasted materials, unaccompanied links and one-line slogans. This is a moderated forum. Comments deemed abusive, offensive, or those containing profanity may not be published.
SES Türkiye's Comments Policy
  • Anonymous translation missing: en_GB, datetime, distance_in_words, almost_x_years

    This will eventually lead to autonomy followed by a demand for land. Let’s not fall into this trap.

  • Anonymous translation missing: en_GB, datetime, distance_in_words, almost_x_years

    It would be naive to believe in the results of such surveys as long as the sword of Damocles (the PKK = the sword of the US) hangs over Kurdish people.

  • Anonymous translation missing: en_GB, datetime, distance_in_words, almost_x_years

    It’s exactly an ignominy, immorality, shamelessness. I censure the ones who wrote this news.

  • Anonymous translation missing: en_GB, datetime, distance_in_words, almost_x_years

    Decent people would believe these. There is nothing else to say.

  • Anonymous translation missing: en_GB, datetime, distance_in_words, almost_x_years

    As a matter of fact, the question “what people in Diyarbakır want” is misleading, wrong and incomplete. Because it would have been more realistic and correct to understand the demands of the people in the entire region in those answers coming from Diyarbakır. I guess we are over-interpreting the results. For example, it says people in Diyarbakır do not want independence and federation. There two reasons for it we must explain. First, emerging societies and communities would not want to get their share of that hypocritical state mechanism. I am not going to analyze that stupid, highly bureaucratic and awkward mechanism called “state”. Kurds have maintained their culture and customs thanks to the fact that they somehow managed to stay away from the state. One should be blind to not see this result here. Secondly, even today some characterless and conscienceless people continue to make fierce comments [about Kurds] without knowing or having visited the region at all in fear of a possible division. The best answer [from the survey] is that more than 80% of them want to be governed in their own free language. You wonder how? These people have expressed demands in this survey. The state is no longer dominant there, where 90% of the people demand democratic autonomous local governments and support the same opinions with the PKK. Let’s leave my opinions aside and look at what those demands are. Even former PM Mesut Yılmaz had understood that the way to the European Union passes through Diyarbakır. However, we still do not understand this fact. Regards and greetings, Cabbar Akgonul

Name: Anonymous - Have your comments posted immediately!

Formatting Help Button